Well, this has been a long-standing topic forever, and actually it deserves updating for sure.
Back when I was designing the Mixing and Mastering curriculum for Dubspot, there was a lot of pressure on me to keep everyone in Live. Dubspot was the (a) church of Ableton Live and although they also taught Logic – Logic sort of enjoyed a second-class citizenship there.
Personally I was a ProTools guy who became a Cubase guy, but there was hardly any Cubase happening at Dubspot at that time.
And, although I was a Cubase user, I always had a deep respect for the sound of in-the-box Logic mixes.
Live in-the-box mixes at that time sounded dull, narrow, fuzzy, and small to me – reverbs seems to collapse and the dynamics were stiff.
And on really big mixes with lots of 3rd party plugins, Live would crash and complain like crazy.
In short, Live seemed like the ultimate sound design, production platform – but not so good for mixing at that time.
The problem seemed to me to be issues in Live regarding plugin-delay-compensation and the internal mix buss summing. These perceptions were entirely impressionistic and not based on any hard data. It’s just the way it sounded to me.
As Live matured, it seemed to me that they fixed some stuff – and the sound seemed to improved quite a bit, maybe around 9 to 9.5.
I am not sure exactly what changed. Some of my very smart friends say that nothing changed.
But what I did notice is the students at nextlevelsound starting completing the Mixing and Mastering Program all in Live and had totally awesome results!
So I changed/updated my opinion about mixing in Live. Lots of my students all over the world now achieve excellent results staying in Live for the entire production/mixing and mastering cycle.
That being said, I still have many students who prefer to use Live for composition, production and sound design – but switch to Logic, Cubase, or Studio One for the final mixing and mastering.
And these students have amazing, world-class results as well.
So I think now that the multi-daw approach is more of a personal option than a recommendation.
Well…that’s the update from me.
Hope that all makes sense.
Let’s keep this conversation going 